The National Security Risk of Failed Ship Contracts
- lhpgop
- Jul 21
- 3 min read
America’s ability to build and maintain a powerful naval fleet is foundational to its national security. But chronic delays, cost overruns, and fraud in warship construction have eroded this foundation. Key fleet programs—Ford‑class carriers, Virginia‑ and Columbia‑class submarines, and Constellation‑class frigates—are years behind schedule, pushing back deployment and risking strategic readiness IDGA+10Business Insider+10CFO Brew+10.
Public shipyards are clogged. Over 40% of submarines presently await maintenance RMC. The USS Enterprise – the next carrier—is reported to be 18–26 months late Business Insider+3RMC+319FortyFive+3. These persistent disruptions mean the Navy can’t reliably project power, even amid a growing Chinese shipbuilding juggernaut USNI News+4RMC+4Business Insider+4.
When Audits Aren’t Enough
• Fraud and Oversight Failures
In 2024, Austal USA, a major Littoral Combat Ship contractor, pleaded guilty to securities fraud and obstruction of federal audits, agreeing to a $24 million fine and probation USNI News+10Department of Justice+10AP News+10. While criminal charges were filed against senior executives, contractors continue delivering substandard work for lucrative DOD contracts CFO BrewWorkBoat.
• Systemic Budget Abuse
Though audits (via DCAA, DoD IG, and GAO) routinely expose cost overruns, they lack enforcement authority. Delays and inflated invoices are flagged—but without criminal follow-up, contractors simply absorb fines as a cost of doing business IDGAArmy Recognition.
Audits + Criminal Justice = Real Accountability
• DOJ & DCIS Must Act More Aggressively
The DOJ and Defence Criminal Investigative Service (DCIS) have clear authority under the False Claims Act and federal statutes. Austal’s case shows DOJ can deploy criminal charges—but prosecutions must escalate and include individual accountability, not just corporate settlements Department of JusticeWorkBoat.
• Mandatory Audit Referrals
Any audit revealing overbilling, false estimates, or fraud should trigger automatic referral to DCIS/DOJ. Doing so ensures that wrongdoing isn't swept aside for administrative fix.
• Civil & Criminal Penalties for Executives
Holding individuals—not just companies—accountable is key. CEOs, CFOs, and program managers must face trial, not escape with mild fines. Past operations like “Ill Wind” prove high-level accountability is possible19FortyFive+4Department of Justice+4Business Insider+4.
The Bigger Picture: Industrial Resilience Still Lacking
Even with prosecutions, deeper failures persist:
Outdated infrastructure and labor shortages, especially in skilled trades like welding and systems integration, cause ongoing delays CSISThe Wall Street Journal.
The Navy’s risk-averse procurement culture routinely greenlights construction before full design maturity—ensuring delays and cost add-ons House Armed Services Committee.
Public shipyards remain underfunded and understaffed. Backlogs in maintenance mean existing assets sit idleRMCCSIS.
China’s dual-use shipyards offer a scalable, agile contrast to US defense-only yards CSISBusiness Insider.
Next Steps: Combining Oversight and Strategy
Layer | Action |
Audits | Tighten DCAA/GAO standards; mandate audits tied to contract payments |
Investigations | DOJ/DCIS to take prompt criminal action on audit findings |
Legislation | Enact laws protecting shipyard/logistics budgets from being diverted |
Infrastructure | Fully implement NAVSEA-NAVFAC SIOP program; modernize yards |
Procurement Reform | Demand completed designs before keel-laying; add contractual penalties |
Workforce Development | Boost pay, training, and retention in public and private yards |
Conclusion
The US shipbuilding sector faces a strategic emergency. Delays, fraud, and contractor malfeasance threaten Navy lethality—and by extension, national defense. While audits uncover issues, only criminal prosecutions, structural reforms, and a strong industrial strategy can reverse this trajectory. The stakes are high: citizens’ security, military readiness, and global deterrence rely on timely, honest shipbuilding.
FYI
If you want to learn more about shipbuilding in the United States or issues with shipping worldwide, you can check into either of these sites
What's going on with Shipping. Sal is great!
G Captain. Worldwide shipping news and issues
Brian Potter on Construction Physics (Substack)
Comments